The text is an extended review of the translations of two commentaries on Aristotle's De int.9 from late antiquity which were published together with articles on the problem of futura contingentia. In a first step, an interpretation-neutral summary of the commentaries is provided, as far as this is possible. In a second step, the different interpretations (labelled the IT - "indefinite truth interpretation", as defended by M.Mignucci / R.Sorabji, - and ETF - the "either-true-or-false interpretation", as defended by N.Kretzmann) are contrasted and evaluated.

back